Light at the end of Boris' dark tunnel?

[Jimgym]

I shall repeat again for the benefit of Lloyd, democracy is always worth it.

[Jim B]

I shall repeat again for the benefit of Lloyd, democracy is always worth it.

Alan

Our democratic system is broken and not fit for purpose; thats the top and bottom of it.
I would suggest watching "The Great Hack" on Netflix which shows how flawed the referendum was.
As I keep informing you the referendum had no legal status and was only advisory. The government's position was to weigh up the pro's and con's of the result and then make a decision on what is best for the UK; that's how our representative democracy is supposed to work, unfortunately every action taken to date has been to save the Conservative party and not what's best for the people.

Jim

[Jimgym]

I shall repeat again for the benefit of Lloyd, democracy is always worth it.

Sorry, but that sounds to me a meaningless sound byte in the same league as "Let's take back control" "Brexit means Brexit" and so forth

Then my point obviously went over your head. I was asked if it was worth it and because it is democracy in action then yes it is worth it. Start complaining when you don’t have the right to vote.

[Jimgym]

I shall repeat again for the benefit of Lloyd, democracy is always worth it.

Alan

Our democratic system is broken and not fit for purpose; thats the top and bottom of it.
I would suggest watching "The Great Hack" on Netflix which shows how flawed the referendum was.
As I keep informing you the referendum had no legal status and was only advisory. The government's position was to weigh up the pro's and con's of the result and then make a decision on what is best for the UK; that's how our representative democracy is supposed to work, unfortunately every action taken to date has been to save the Conservative party and not what's best for the people.

Jim

Jim it was made very clear that the British people were given the choice. I don’t recall ANY. Remained complaining that it wasn’t binding before the results came in. I’ve no doubt whatsoever they would be singing a different tune if the vote had been different. Irrespective of how our system is, we live in a democracy, good or bad.

[Jimgward]

There are none so blind as those who will not see

https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=i&rct=j ... 2339846935

[Jim B]

I shall repeat again for the benefit of Lloyd, democracy is always worth it.

Alan

Our democratic system is broken and not fit for purpose; thats the top and bottom of it.
I would suggest watching "The Great Hack" on Netflix which shows how flawed the referendum was.
As I keep informing you the referendum had no legal status and was only advisory. The government's position was to weigh up the pro's and con's of the result and then make a decision on what is best for the UK; that's how our representative democracy is supposed to work, unfortunately every action taken to date has been to save the Conservative party and not what's best for the people.

Jim

Jim it was made very clear that the British people were given the choice. I don’t recall ANY. Remained complaining that it wasn’t binding before the results came in. I’ve no doubt whatsoever they would be singing a different tune if the vote had been different. Irrespective of how our system is, we live in a democracy, good or bad.

Alan
We do not live in a democracy, you have to realise that.
Remember BoatyMacboatface or when the people in Lancashire voted to ban fracking and the government overturned the decision.
It appears democracy only matters if it agreed with your point of view.
As Mark Twain quoted, "If voting made a difference they wouldn't let us do it"

[Jimgym]

Jim we are a democratic country. Which is why it irritates me when Remainers conveniently ignore that fact. Comparing the very clear referendum to anything else is frankly pointless. The people voted out, like it or not. Respect that decision. Democracy matters very much to me whatever the decisions are, something a minority of Remainers would do very well to remember.

[Jim B]

Jim we are a democratic country. Which is why it irritates me when Remainers conveniently ignore that fact. Comparing the very clear referendum to anything else is frankly pointless. The people voted out, like it or not. Respect that decision. Democracy matters very much to me whatever the decisions are, something a minority of Remainers would do very well to remember.

Alan
I think we're going round in circles here; you believe the referendum was legally binding even though I've posted numerous links proving that referendums in the UK are only advisory. Democracy is important to me but I don't accept that lying and cheating is acceptable in the Democratic Process whereas it appears it is to many leavers in as much the end justifies the means.
The Supreme Court returned a judgement that as the Referendum was only advisory they couldn't declare it void and because it is only advisory they cannot order it to be re_run.
At the end of the day it depends on what sort of Democratic System you're prepared to accept.

Below is a link confirm what I write.

Jim

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-44856992

[Firefly]

Lloyd

Again the article you quote is full of 'potential, could' etc. No-one knows yet how things will pan out.


As for 'dear old Jackie' a T shirt I saw recently said it all, " thinking that I'm just an old lady was your first mistake".


Jackie

[Jimgym]

Jim we are a democratic country. Which is why it irritates me when Remainers conveniently ignore that fact. Comparing the very clear referendum to anything else is frankly pointless. The people voted out, like it or not. Respect that decision. Democracy matters very much to me whatever the decisions are, something a minority of Remainers would do very well to remember.

Alan
I think we're going round in circles here; you believe the referendum was legally binding even though I've posted numerous links proving that referendums in the UK are only advisory. Democracy is important to me but I don't accept that lying and cheating is acceptable in the Democratic Process whereas it appears it is to many leavers in as much the end justifies the means.
The Supreme Court returned a judgement that as the Referendum was only advisory they couldn't declare it void and because it is only advisory they cannot order it to be re_run.
At the end of the day it depends on what sort of Democratic System you're prepared to accept.

Below is a link confirm what I write.

Jim

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-44856992

Jim, I am confused as to who you keep telling me the referendum was advisory. I am well aware of that fact, as I have previously told you. I have also said that Britain was offered it as a choice to either stay or leave. I don't have time to find the exact quote from Cameron. As to lies, BOTH sides we and are culpable there. I am prepared to accept a system whereby the votes of the majority are implanted in an election, referendum, anything. However it seems some people only want it when it suites them. Thankfully I am not in that category.

[Jimgym]

The vote was Remain or leave. Very simple. Where is your proof that leave voters imagined anything?

[Jimgym]

"I believe" does not state fact requiring proof.Nor could you ever prove what is in people's minds

Then why use it as the basis of your argument?

[Jimgym]

The vote was Remain or leave. Very simple. Where is your proof that leave voters imagined anything?

I really hope they were imagining something,rather than just on a whim,or coin toss

Try asking them rather than making things up to suit your point of view. Always better to do that rather than ascribe things to people without checking first.

[Jim B]

Alan
I agree a majority advised the government they wished to leave the EU but that's all it was, advice. If I asked you for advice it would then be up to me to decide whether to act on it or not. This advice of referendum was then put before parliament for the members to decide whether to act on the advice provided. A majority of MPs decided not to accept the advice given as they feel it will be detrimental to the good of the country and that's the position we find ourselves in; that is representative democracy which is our system. On the issue of leaving the EU you want to use direct democracy; you can't change horses half way because the existing system doesn't provide what you want.

Jim

[Jimgward]

Democracy isnt a one-vote, final decision. That’s why parliament often takes votes, passes to the Lord’s, they amend, send back to commons, then vote on the amended law. NEVER, pass a law, put it into practice and never every change it

[Jimgym]

Democracy isnt a one-vote, final decision. That’s why parliament often takes votes, passes to the Lord’s, they amend, send back to commons, then vote on the amended law. NEVER, pass a law, put it into practice and never every change it

*sigh* Yet again, we were offered a vote, it was made very very clear that it would be up to the voters to stay or leave. Why do Remainers continue to ignore this incredibly simple fact? It had NOTHING to do with any other vote. Remainers lecturing on democracy whilst trying to deny others the very same thing is quite frankly laughable.

[Jimgym]

Alan
I agree a majority advised the government they wished to leave the EU but that's all it was, advice. If I asked you for advice it would then be up to me to decide whether to act on it or not. This advice of referendum was then put before parliament for the members to decide whether to act on the advice provided. A majority of MPs decided not to accept the advice given as they feel it will be detrimental to the good of the country and that's the position we find ourselves in; that is representative democracy which is our system. On the issue of leaving the EU you want to use direct democracy; you can't change horses half way because the existing system doesn't provide what you want.

Jim

Jim I’m not going to continue to repeat myself. You obviously do not want to accept the result of a democratic vote. Repeating yourself won’t change anything. It saddens me that people are so opposed to democracy.

[Jimgym]

Democracy isnt a one-vote, final decision. That’s why parliament often takes votes, passes to the Lord’s, they amend, send back to commons, then vote on the amended law. NEVER, pass a law, put it into practice and never every change it

Erm.... exactly, but that is what Boris is trying to do bypushing forward his final decision and avoiding a parliamentary vote

He is pushing what the majority of those who voted wanted. To leave the EU.

[Jim B]

Alan
I agree a majority advised the government they wished to leave the EU but that's all it was, advice. If I asked you for advice it would then be up to me to decide whether to act on it or not. This advice of referendum was then put before parliament for the members to decide whether to act on the advice provided. A majority of MPs decided not to accept the advice given as they feel it will be detrimental to the good of the country and that's the position we find ourselves in; that is representative democracy which is our system. On the issue of leaving the EU you want to use direct democracy; you can't change horses half way because the existing system doesn't provide what you want.

Jim

Jim I’m not going to continue to repeat myself. You obviously do not want to accept the result of a democratic vote. Repeating yourself won’t change anything. It saddens me that people are so opposed to democracy.

Alan it saddens me that many highly intelligent people don't appear to understand how the British "Democratic System" works.
Jim

[Jimgym]

Alan
I agree a majority advised the government they wished to leave the EU but that's all it was, advice. If I asked you for advice it would then be up to me to decide whether to act on it or not. This advice of referendum was then put before parliament for the members to decide whether to act on the advice provided. A majority of MPs decided not to accept the advice given as they feel it will be detrimental to the good of the country and that's the position we find ourselves in; that is representative democracy which is our system. On the issue of leaving the EU you want to use direct democracy; you can't change horses half way because the existing system doesn't provide what you want.

Jim

Jim I’m not going to continue to repeat myself. You obviously do not want to accept the result of a democratic vote. Repeating yourself won’t change anything. It saddens me that people are so opposed to democracy.

Alan it saddens me that many highly intelligent people don't appear to understand how the British "Democratic System" works.
Jim

Oh I know Jim, apparently leave doesn’t actually mean that for some “R” voters........